Education
Louisiana Panel Approves Ten Commandments Displays For Water Polo Harassment Response
BATON ROUGE, La.—In a unanimous decision Wednesday, the Louisiana Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal ruled that public schools across the state are authorized to display the Ten Commandments on campus grounds, framing the move as a direct response to escalating behavioral metrics in student athletics. The ruling stems from a newly formed educational coordination board's mandate to address 'moral deficits' identified in school sports programs, particularly water polo.
'After reviewing the data from incidents like the Harvard-Westlake case, we determined that visual reminders of core principles could serve as a preventive measure,' stated Judge Beatrice Morrison, speaking from the courthouse. Morrison referenced the recent California lawsuit in which a water polo player alleged years of sexual and racial harassment by teammates while school staff failed to intervene. 'Displaying these commandments offers a clear, passive enforcement mechanism. It's about setting a baseline.'
The court's 47-page opinion specifies that each plaque must be 'positioned no higher than seven feet from floor level for optimal student visibility' and details how $1.2 million initially allocated for swim lane repainting and anti-hazing training will instead fund custom bronze plaques. Installation sites will include 'areas proximate to aquatic facilities where behavioral lapses are most frequently documented,' according to the document.
Education officials have since convened a Ten Commandments Implementation Task Force, which will oversee the rollout. Its first action was to lower the program's success benchmarks. Initially aimed at eliminating misconduct, the goal was revised to 'reducing reportable incidents by 10% within two years.' Last month, the target shifted again to 'maintaining current incident levels while improving perceived moral tone.'
'We're not trying to solve the problem, just to show we're aware of it,' said Dr. Lionel Pratt, head of the task force, during a press briefing. He presented charts indicating that schools with 'existing virtue-based signage' saw no change in misconduct rates but reported higher satisfaction in staff surveys. 'That's a win. If people feel better about the rules, that's practically the same as following them.'
An internal task force memo obtained by this outlet explicitly frames plaque installation as meeting compliance requirements regardless of outcomes. 'Once visual accountability is established through mounted displays, the institution has fulfilled its obligation to address moral climate,' the document states, adding that 'subsequent incident reports would merely indicate the need for supplemental visual reinforcement.'
Critics, including the Louisiana ACLU, have filed motions challenging the displays as unconstitutional, but the appeals court dismissed them, citing the 'urgent need for symbolic governance.' Meanwhile, water polo coaches statewide have been instructed to hold pre-game meetings under the newly installed plaques. At one Baton Rouge high school, players now recite a modified pledge that includes 'honoring the signage' as a team objective.
With evaluation scheduled for next year, preliminary data shows the primary outcome has been a 300% increase in orders for laminated commandment prints from a single state-approved vendor. In the lone school that has completed installation, a water polo player who asked not to be named said, 'We mostly just see it when we're getting yelled at. It's like a backdrop for lectures.'
Kicker: The task force's next meeting will focus on expanding the program to address student cheating, using the same signage but with a new metric: 'visible guilt reduction.'